Conspiracy Theories
Conspiracy Theories have been around for a very long time, and do not show any signs of going away any time soon. In fact they are proliferating at what seems like an exponential rate. This article endeavours to explain the root causes, the range, the arguments used that underpin them, and counter argument techniques.
Merriam-Webster's definition of a Conspiracy Theory : "a theory that explains an event or set of circumstances as the result of a secret plot by usually powerful conspirators."
The Oxford English Dictionary defines conspiracy theory as "the theory that an event or phenomenon occurs as a result of a conspiracy between interested parties; spec. a belief that some covert but influential agency (typically political in motivation and oppressive in intent) is responsible for an unexplained event."
Historical Context
Successful
conspiracy theories generally tap into a society's anxieties and obsession, and they always have the right villain, who are generally viewed with suspicion, and often portrayed as secretive and dangerous. There is a perception of a 'powerful set of elites' that are covertly manipulating society via any means open to them. In 331 bce people were dropping dead in their droves for unknown reasons. The blame was put on a group of women who were actually concocting lethal potions, for reasons unknown. Hence, they were scapegoated for what turned out to be an epidemic of disease.
Image by frhuynh
There is always a useful scapegoat at the heart of any conspiracy theory, be it the 'Deep State', or Jewish people. Historically, Jewish people have been persecuted, and have been the target of anti-semitism since the foundation of their religion and ideology. The term anti-semitism was coined in 1879 by Wilhelm Marr to designate the anti-Jewish campaigns under way in central Europe at that time. The term is actually a misnomer, as Jewish people are not the only 'Semites'.
Exposure to 'media' that endorses conspiracy theories, increases belief. Social media plays a vital role in proliferating such exposure by way of algorithms. Films and documentaries may also 'inadvertently' increase the spread, and solidify, existing beliefs in conspiracies. Britannica states:
"There is evidence that viewing the Oliver Stone movie JFK (1991) increased belief in a conspiracy to assassinate Kennedy and decreased belief in the official account that Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone. A further outcome was that, compared with people who were about to view the movie, those who had seen it expressed less interest in political participation. It may be that distrust of those in power predicts and is caused by belief in government conspiracies."
"Conspiracy theories once limited to fringe audiences have become commonplace in mass media, the internet, and social media, emerging as a cultural phenomenon of the late 20th and early 21st centuries.They are widespread around the world and are often commonly believed, some even being held by the majority of the population. Interventions to reduce the occurrence of conspiracy beliefs include maintaining an open society and improving the analytical thinking skills of the general public." - Wikipedia Types
Michael Barkun has identified three classifications of conspiracy theory.
Barkun's three types:
Event conspiracy theories: Examples may include such conspiracies theories as 9/11, the spread of AIDS, and Covid-19.
Systemic conspiracy theories: This is a common scenario in conspiracy theories that focus on the alleged machinations of Jews, Freemasons, Communism, or the Catholic Church.
Superconspiracy theories: Such theories link multiple alleged conspiracies together hierarchically. At the summit is a distant but all-powerful evil force.
Range
From Rome to Covid-19
Rome: 331 bce - A group of women were suspected of the deaths of a large swathe of the inhabitants of Rome. It has been later stated that it was an epidemic of plague.
Nero:
A widespread conspiracy theory pertaining to the death of Emperor Nero. Nero took his own life in 68 CE and theories sprouted up saying that he had in fact faked his own death. Also, that he would come back from the dead to terrorise his 'enemies'.
JFK: A multitude of theories surround the death of JFK. Some based on individuals and organisations, and others a combination of both. It is been named 'The mother of all conspiracy theories' as it has been so widespread and written about so many times.
George Soros: Conspiracy theories abound as to the intent of Soros. They claim that he uses his wealth to fund 'organisations' such as Antifa, and that he funds far-left activism, and influences governments worldwide. This is linked to anti-Semitism, as Soros is Jewish.
New World Order: States that a group of international elites, or Illuminati, are secretly manipulating governments, in order to rule the world.
Deep State: "an alleged secret network of especially non elected government officials and sometimes private entities (as in the financial services and defense industries) operating extralegally to influence and enact government policy" - Merriam-Webster
Image by tunnelmotions
Illuminati: (plural of illuminatus, 'enlightened'), "Central to some of the more widely known and elaborate conspiracy theories, the Illuminati have been depicted as lurking in the shadows and pulling the strings and levers of power in dozens of novels, films, television shows, comics, video games, and music videos." - Wikipedia
Anti-Semitism: Since the middle ages conspiracy theories have abounded in relation to Jewish people. From poisoning wells, to ritually consuming the blood of Christians (specifically children). Much is to do with apportioning blame for the death of 'Christ', but much is also about creating a convenient scapegoat for the purposes of pointing to 'the other', as the ones at fault. These tactics have been, and continue to be, used by regimes from both the 'left' and the 'right'. From the former Soviet Union, to the Nazis. Anti-Semitic tropes are still in use today by neo-nazis and the hard/far-right. The now debunked tome 'The Protocols of the Elders of Zion' has been referenced with great effect by anti-Semites.
Covid-19: Many weird, and not so wonderful, theories have erupted since the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic. These include microchips being injected into those being vaccinated, with Bill Gates being the alleged mastermind behind this. Also, that the vaccines will somehow alter people's DNA in some way so as to create a subordinate, and submissive population that is easier to control, and do the bidding of the so-called 'elites'.
Psychology
Türkay Salim Nefes suggests that one of the most important characteristics of conspiracy theories is their attempt to unveil the "real but hidden" power relations in social groups. Belief in conspiracy theories can be harmful or pathological, and are strongly associated with the mental health disorder of Schizotypy. Conspiracy theories often make use of seemingly complicated and 'analytical' arguments, that appeal to those who believe themselves to have good critical thinking capabilities. In such cases the Dunning-Kruger Effect comes into play, in which people tend to believe they know more than they actually do. Belief in conspiracy theories is very often 'emotion driven'. That is most likely a fundamental reason as to the popularity of 'Pizzagate', and its theme of paedophilia.
Conclusion
A great many conspiracy theories will intermingle and will either stem from, or lead to, anti-Semitic tropes, or full-on antisemitism. There appears to be a central, underlying theme to many 'theories' by which a secret, shadowy cabal of highly influential people are engaged in a mass take-over of governments, and seek to subordinate the world's population by means of pushing immigration, controlling world finances, controlling academia, and also using bio-warfare techniques to undermine the 'purity of bloodlines/ethnicity'.
Q-anon, Antivax, Anti-mask, hard/far-right anti-woke, anti-Antifa, Anti-BLM, Climate change sceptics, anti-intellectuals; all have the potential of dragging, what used to be fairly reasonable individuals, down the rabbit-hole of conspiracy theories.The most effective conspiracy theories are built upon kernels of truth. That is what makes them so effective. And unfortunately, many will lead to anti-Semitism and racism.
The advent of the internet, and social media specifically, has allowed for the rise and proliferation of conspiracy theories that may not otherwise have seen the light of day. These are dangerous times in which we all need to be wary of any new information that is presented to us. Notable, and influential mainstream figures, such as Russell Brand and Joe Rogan, are now flirting with conspiracy theorists. We now need to guard against the appealing 'clickbait' headlines that may inadvertently lead us 'Down the Rabbit Hole'.
"Conspiracism serves the needs of diverse political and social groups in America and elsewhere. It identifies elites, blames them for economic and social catastrophes, and assumes that things will be better once popular action can remove them from positions of power. As such, conspiracy theories do not typify a particular epoch or ideology." - Frank P. Mintz
Sources
Comments
Post a Comment